City Assessment Value vs. Market Value: How closely related ARE they?

by Bo on February 3, 2010

Print This Post Print This Post

After reading this, be sure to check out my website


Hello Everyone:

In the past couple of weeks, I’ve had 3 different people make reference to “City Assessment Value” of homes.  These folks were placing a lot of weight on the C.A. of houses, and were questioning whether the “Listing Price” of a certain house was realistic, or whether it was too high.

Now, anyone who has ever read any of my blog, or spoken to me directly, knows that in my opinion, “Listing Prices” in Winnipeg are most often set unrealistically LOW….  so having people suggest that the listing price was too high was something new….:-)

I explained that City Assessment has, in actuality, very little to do with real Market Value.  There are several reasons for this, including:

1) City Assessment does not know about recent improvements to the home, such as New Furnace, New Windows, Fully Finished Basements, etc

2) City Assessment does not take into consideration any additions to the home, such as sunrooms, family rooms, swimming pools

3) City Assessment is unable to keep up with fast changing market increases in Winnipeg.

.

So then I looked at some recent sales, going back 6 months, in a variety of neighbourhoods thruout Winnipeg, and compared SOLD prices with LISTING prices an City Assessment values.  I hope you’ll find these as interesting as I did:

.

Neighbourhood        Style                      List $              Sold $           City Assessment

River Heights                Bng                         219,900            219,900            196,000

River Heights               2-St.                        279,900            295,200            251,000

Charleswood                  Bng                        249,900            249,900            226,000

Charleswood                  2-St                       289,900            282,000            231,000

LindenWoods                2-St                        289,900            297,000            276,000

River Park South            Bng                        199,900            232,500            179,000

River Park South            Bng                        249,900            285,700            237,000

River Park South            2-St                       299,900            280,200           223,000

Island Lakes                     Bng                      239,000             245,000           196,000

St.James/Assin.              2-St                      279,900              279,000           242,000

St.James/Assin.              Bng                        249,000            280,500           211,000

W/Kildonan                     Bng                        209,900            217,000           188,000

Garden Grove                  Bng                        239,900            239,000           204,000

Some astute folks will no doubt point out that some homes actually sold for less-than-asking, but that’s the subject for a different blog post altogether.

If you’re thinking of selling your house or condo, and would like to know what the Market Value is for your property, please contact me anytime…..I love to help.

Bo  333-2202

You can find my website at WinnipegHomeFinder

You can follow me on Twitter


Bo Kauffmann of Remax Performance Realty is the recipient of the 2009 Silver Medallion Award from Winnipeg REALTORS®, the Platinum Club Award from Remax, and is one of Winnipeg's top-producing Real Estate Agents.  Check out his website at WinnipegHomeFinder, follow him on Twitter or email him at boknowshomes@gmail.com
. .

Free Market Evaluation and Blog-Post subscription

Thinking of Selling your home?  Lots of agents offer the so-called "Free Internet Evaluation", which is worth about as much as people pay for it: Nothing.  In order to set a realistic 'Asking Price', a qualified REALTOR® (or Appraiser) will have to come to your home for an actual inspection.  So if you're thinking of selling your house or condo.... simply fill out this form and I will contact you.
Market Evaluation
* indicates required


If you enjoyed this post, please consider 'bookmarking' it or sending it to one of the services above. Thank you very much!

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: